Gregory G. H. Rihn (milwaukeesfs) wrote,
Gregory G. H. Rihn

Burrahobbits, 06-22-04, Picnic and “Merlin of the Oak Wood.”

On Tuesday evening, we gathered on the lovely deck at the residence of Peter Schuessler for the Burrahobbits cookout, which has become an annual affair. As usual, Peter was master of the grill, providing delicious burgers and bratwurst, and mixmaster Dave Hoose made his famous Martinis for anyone that wanted one. We brought my devilled eggs, and Georgie made strawberry shortcake, with fresh strawberries from the West Allis Farmers’ Market and homemade “cakes”. Other salads and snacks were also on offer, so, as usual, it was a delicious time. Even after the food and drink, we managed to have a cogent discussion of “The Merlin of the Oak Wood,” by Anne Chamberlin. This book is the second of her “Joan of Arc Tapestries” series, which has so far chronicled the youth of Gilles de Rais and birth of Jehanne D’Arc in “The Merlin of St. Giles’s Well.” “Oak Wood” continues following the lives of the two main characters as Gilles grows into his career as a warrior and becomes involved in the unsavory politics of France, and Jehanne as she awakens to the arcane life of the earth around her and eventually decides to claim her position as “La Pucelle.” What’s frustrating is that this last event takes place in literally the last pages of this volume, which makes one wonder why both books, which are of modest length by modern standards, couldn’t have been combined into one. Both together would hardly add up to one Jordan or Modesitt chunk. However, one suspects that the inevitable third volume which will have to cover the three years of Jehanne’s glory and martyrdom, would then seem meagerly slim, even padded out with Chamberlin’s somewhat didactic exposition of ideas about the survival of Pagan practices in the war-torn France of the Hundred Years War.

This was one of the most discussed points of the book, not so much in the possibility of continued ancient rituals, which isn’t that unreasonable, but Chamberlin’s fictionalized idea of the underlying philosophy. The concept of “balance” as a goal isn’t new, but the old ways priests’ balancing of “good” and “evil” seems somewhat disturbing, particularly as it leads Yann to take some pretty nasty actions in pursuit of his purpose. We did not think that “moral ambiguity” was a much-debated concept in those troubled times, but “desperate times call for desperate measures” seems to be the byword of everyone in the books and seems at odds with the doctine that means affect ends which is a tenet of much mystical study.
  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded